Asked by: Attilio Gueldenpfennig
asked in category: General Last Updated: 15th February, 2020

What did Hamilton argue Federalist 84?

Being a federalist, Hamilton believed that a Bill of Rights was both unnecessary and dangerous for the American people. He believed that the Constitution already guaranteed a separation of governmental power and individual rights, it just wasn't flat out stated.

Click to see full answer.


Furthermore, what is the Federalist Paper 84 about?

Federalist No. 84 is notable for presenting the idea that a Bill of Rights was not a necessary component of the proposed United States Constitution. The constitution, as originally written, is to specifically enumerate and protect the rights of the people.

One may also ask, what did the Federalist Papers argue? What the Federalist Papers Said. In the Federalist Papers, Hamilton, Jay and Madison argued that the decentralization of power that existed under the Articles of Confederation prevented the new nation from becoming strong enough to compete on the world stage, or to quell internal insurrections such as Shays's Rebellion

Likewise, people ask, why did Hamilton who authored Federalist No 84 argue that including a bill of rights would pose a danger to the new nation?

Hamilton argues that a bill of rights would not only be unnecessary, but dangerous. A bill of rights would, for instance, attempt to limit certain governmental powers which are not even granted. This is so because the state and national governments will be rivals for power.

Who argued in Federalist No 84 that the Constitution itself even without amendments was a Bill of Rights?

The Federalist Papers, specifically Federalist No. 84, are notable for their opposition to what later became the United States Bill of Rights. Hamilton didn't support the addition of a Bill of Rights because he believed that the Constitution wasn't written to limit the people.

37 Related Question Answers Found

What did Federalist Paper 10 say?

Why did the Federalists believe the Bill of Rights unnecessary?

What are the most compelling ideas behind Federalist #84?


What was the main purpose of the Federalist Papers?

What do you understand by the term federalism?

What was the reaction by other founding fathers who were concerned about the original Constitution?


What is the main idea of Federalist Paper #51?

What does the Federalist Paper 47 mean?

What were the three main ideas in the Federalist Papers?


Why is Federalist 70 important?

Why was Hamilton better than Jefferson?

Do you agree with Hamilton or Jefferson?


Why was Alexander Hamilton a federalist?